Posts

The £4 Billion Narrative: What Parliament Was Told — and What Was Already Known

Image
Are £4 Billion in Child Maintenance Arrears Really Owed? For years, the UK has been told that around £4 billion in unpaid child maintenance arrears is owed by parents and labelled as labelled as deadbeat dads/ delinquent dads. However, evidence given to the Public Accounts Committee and findings from the National Audit Office show that much of this figure is based on historical estimation methods, incorrect assessments, and debt that is unlikely to ever be collected . This means the headline figure does not represent a clear, enforceable amount owed — but a legacy total that includes disputed, inflated, and in many cases uncollectable arrears . This article explains what Parliament was actually told — and why the £4 billion narrative is deeply misleading. “£3.8–£4 billion in unpaid child maintenance is owed by non-paying parents.” This figure has been repeated across media, Parliament, and stakeholder reports — often presented as evidence of widespread non-compliance by paying ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Selective Access: Why Does Gingerbread Get the Minister, While Others Are Refused?

Image
In recent weeks, campaign groups and charities have once again been invited into Parliament to brief Ministers on the Child Maintenance Service (CMS). Among them, Gingerbread — a well-funded organisation with established political access — has been able to present its case directly to government. But what happens when other voices ask for the same access? The answer is now in black and white. The Refusal A formal request for a meeting was made by STOPSuicides UK , alongside journalists and campaigners, to discuss serious concerns including: deaths linked to Department for Work and Pensions systems safeguarding failures transparency in investigations The response from the Minister, Baroness Sherlock , was clear: “I am not in a position to meet at this point… I do not feel I could add anything meaningful beyond the information that has already been shared.” This is not a scheduling issue. This is a refusal to engage . What Was Being Asked? This was not a trivial r...
Post a Comment
Read more

When the Minister Won’t Meet: What the Sherlock Letter Reveals About CMS Accountability

Image
Selective engagement, limited scrutiny, and the voices Parliament chooses to hear Introduction A recent letter from Baroness Sherlock raises serious questions about how concerns surrounding the Child Maintenance Service (CMS) are handled at the highest level of government. The issue is not just what was said. It is what was refused. A Request for Engagement — Declined Campaigners from STOPSuicide UK , alongside journalists and advocates, requested a meeting with the Minister to discuss: Safeguarding failures Transparency concerns Cases involving serious harm and death The response was clear: The Minister declined to meet, stating she was “not in a position” to do so and could not “add anything meaningful.” This was not a casual request. It involved: A recognised advocacy group Investigative journalism Concerns linked to real-world harm Yet the door remained closed. Deflection and Scope Narrowing The letter shifts focus away from the core concerns: The matters raised “sit outside of my ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Domestic Abuse Statistics Tell a Bigger Story — So Why Is Only One Side Used in CMS Reform?

Image
When evidence is selective, policy becomes unbalanced The Missing Context in the CMS Debate Recent briefings by Gingerbread and partner organisations have placed domestic abuse at the centre of Child Maintenance Service (CMS) reform. That matters. Domestic abuse is real, serious, and must be addressed. But there is a growing problem in how the evidence is being presented: Only part of the picture is being used. What the Official Statistics Actually Show According to the Office for National Statistics: Around 2.2 million women and 1.5 million men experienced domestic abuse in the last year 👉 https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/crimeandjustice/bulletins/domesticabuseinenglandandwalesoverview/november2025 Approximately 6.5% of men experience domestic abuse annually 👉 https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/crimeandjustice/articles/domesticabusevictimcharacteristicsenglandandwales/yearendingmarch2025 Further analysis indicates: Men make up a significant prop...
Post a Comment
Read more

CMS Reform Is Built on Half the Evidence — Where Are the Paying Parents?

Image
 A direct response to Gingerbread’s “Fix the CMS” research and domestic abuse briefing What the Research Is Based On The key report (“Fix the CMS”) is built on: 24 interviews 1,622 survey responses FOI data from the Department for Work and Pensions 👉 That matters. This is mixed-method research — but it is still: experience-led, not a full system audit What the Research Claims 1. The CMS as a Site of Economic Abuse The central argument is clear: Abusers can use the CMS to continue coercive control Examples cited include: Withholding payments Paying late or unpredictably Using the payment system to harass Forcing contact through Direct Pay This aligns with wider domestic abuse sector evidence that: Withholding maintenance can be a form of coercive control 2. High Prevalence of Abuse The research relies on figures such as: Around 58% of CMS applicants disclosing domestic abuse 👉 But this requires context: It is self-disclosure , not verified prevalence It is drawn largely from rece...
Post a Comment
Read more