Domestic Abuse Statistics Tell a Bigger Story — So Why Is Only One Side Used in CMS Reform?

When evidence is selective, policy becomes unbalanced




The Missing Context in the CMS Debate

Recent briefings by Gingerbread and partner organisations have placed domestic abuse at the centre of Child Maintenance Service (CMS) reform.

That matters.

Domestic abuse is real, serious, and must be addressed.

But there is a growing problem in how the evidence is being presented:

Only part of the picture is being used.

What the Official Statistics Actually Show

According to the Office for National Statistics:

Further analysis indicates:

Why This Matters for CMS Policy

The current policy narrative focuses heavily on:

  • Abuse against receiving parents
  • Non-payment as a form of control
  • The need for stronger enforcement

But the official data shows clearly:

Domestic abuse is not one-directional.

The Risk of Selective Evidence

When statistics are presented without full context, it creates:

  • A skewed understanding of how abuse operates
  • Policy responses that assume one type of victim
  • Systems that overlook harm in other forms

The Other Side That Isn’t Being Discussed

While non-payment is rightly scrutinised, there is little discussion of:

  • Disputed or incorrect arrears
  • Enforcement applied before disputes are resolved
  • Payments already being made but not recognised
  • The impact of enforcement on Paying Parents

When the System Itself Applies Pressure

The Child Maintenance Service has the power to:

  • Deduct earnings
  • Enforce payments
  • Escalate action administratively

If those powers are used on incorrect or disputed figures, the effect is clear:

Financial pressure is applied without full scrutiny.

A Missing Voice in Parliament

Organisations like Gingerbread have a seat at the table.

But where is the structured representation for:

  • Paying Parents
  • Those disputing arrears
  • Those affected by enforcement error

The Bigger Question

If domestic abuse affects both men and women…

And the CMS affects both Receiving and Paying Parents…

Why is only one side being reflected in the evidence used to shape reform?

The Wider Context

This issue cannot be separated from the broader questions around arrears and enforcement:

👉 https://the-4billion-pound-lie.blogspot.com/2025/10/the-4-billion-lie.html
👉 https://the-4billion-pound-lie.blogspot.com/2026/04/the-double-cost-of-cms-117-million-in.html
👉 https://the-4billion-pound-lie.blogspot.com/2026/04/selective-scrutiny-who-gets-heard-on.html
👉 https://the-4billion-pound-lie.blogspot.com/2025/10/gingerbreads-misrepresentation-of-child.html

Conclusion

Domestic abuse statistics tell a bigger story than the one currently being used in the CMS debate.

Recognising this does not diminish any victim.

It strengthens the integrity of policy.

Final Point

Domestic abuse is not one-directional — yet current CMS reform discussions are built as if it is.

Until the full picture is recognised:

  • Policy will remain unbalanced
  • Safeguards will be incomplete
  • And reform risks addressing only half the problem

This isn’t about denying abuse.

It’s about ensuring the evidence used to shape policy reflects the reality of everyone affected.





Explore all topics: [Site Map]


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The £4 Billion Lie

Image
How the State and Gingerbread Framed Innocent Parents As Deadbeat Dads UK Parliament – Palace of Westminster, home of the Work and Pensions Select Committee and the Public Accounts Committee that examined Child Support Agency arrears. For more than thirty years, the British Government and its favoured charity partner, Gingerbread , have cast one group of citizens as villains: the Non  Resident Parent . Labelled “deadbeat dads,” they’ve been accused of failing their children. Behind that slogan lies a manufactured scandal — a fictitious debt worth billions, created by the Child Support Agency (CSA)  on the 1993 -2003 child support schemes and continues to be collected by the Child Maintenance Service (CMS). The Henshaw Report (2006): The Warning They Ignored In 2006, the Government commissioned Sir David Henshaw to review the failing Child Support Agency. His report, Recovering Child Support – Routes to Responsibility , was blunt: “The Agency has not delivered agai...
Read more

Gingerbread’s Misrepresentation of Child-Maintenance Arrears

Image
  Findings Summary:  Between 2016 and 2024, the charity Gingerbread (No. 230750) repeatedly asserted in media articles, parliamentary briefings, and reports that £3.8 – £4 billion in unpaid child-maintenance arrears was owed to single parents. This figure appeared in The Guardian , BBC News , The Mirror , The Sun , Raeside Chisholm Solicitors , iNews , and Early Day Motion 575 (19 October 2016) — all explicitly citing Gingerbread as the source. However, official findings from the National Audit Office (NAO), Work and Pensions Committee, and Public Accounts Committee (2009 – 2024) confirmed that the overwhelming majority of this debt was fictitious, inflated, or owed to the Secretary of State, not to parents with care. The House of Commons Library Briefing Paper CBP-7776 (2021) recorded that, of the £3.7 billion in legacy CSA arrears, only £0.1 – £0.6 billion was realistically recoverable. On 7 July 2020, the Charity Commission for England and Wales upheld a public comp...
Read more

Is the Child Maintenance Service Value for Money?

 Public services are not judged on cost alone. They are judged on whether they deliver value. Under the framework used by the National Audit Office, public spending must be assessed against three key principles: Economy – is money being spent carefully? Efficiency – are resources being used well? Effectiveness – is the system achieving its intended outcomes? These are the standards applied across Government. The question is whether the Child Maintenance Service meets them. The Cost of the System The Child Maintenance Service costs approximately: £116 million per year to operate This is public money, funded by taxpayers, and justified on the basis that it supports children by ensuring financial maintenance is paid. The Cost of the Outcomes Recent analysis based on Freedom of Information data has identified: 35 suicides among paying parents in a six-month period Using Parliament’s estimate of £1.67 million per suicide , this equates to: ~£117 million per year That is broadly equi...
Read more